This is a horror story. I would imagine that he has stolen so much from her; her ability to trust, her ability to sleep deeply, her enjoyment of sex, positive feelings about her body. How dare he touch her without her permission? How dare he use her in this way? What an evil man, a horrible sexual predator.
The jury found Lee Setford guilty. The verdict was unanimous. He was sentenced to 5 years in prison and will have to register as a sex offender. It would almost seem that the UK justice system has got this one right, well as right as such a paltry sentence can be. Sadly the judge, Michael Mettyear managed to undo this completely with his comments.
He began by praising Setford's good character; "It is sad to see a man of generally good character in the dock for such a serious offense."
Yep, you read that right. A convicted rapist, who took advantage of a sleeping, extremely drunk woman, who wasn't even awake to say no, has generally good character. He doesn't sound like a very nice guy to me.
It gets worse, basically, Mettyear cannot hide his opinion that responsibility for rape lies with the victim and not the perpetrator; "It was almost out of the blue that two girls turned up late at night, very very drunk, at your home. The victim was the worse for drink out of the two of them. She was completely out of it. I accept that evidence. She was a pretty girl who you fancied. You simply could not resist. You had sex with her."
She was completely out of it...... the judge accepts that the victim was so drunk that she was an easy target as evidence for the rapist's good character.
She was a pretty girl who you fancied...... oh well, that's alright then, if you fancy someone, you're entitled to rape them because you will enjoy it. What a neanderthal.
You had sex with her..... Actually, he raped her. He attacked her and raped her. There is a difference.
Mettyear also said that he doesn't consider Setford a 'classic rapist,' Setford doesn't hide in bushes and jump out on women walking past. He doesn't bundle them into his car and rape them at knifepoint. No he just waits until they are paralytic, unconscious and willingly in his house before he attacks them. I am not sure how this can be considered a good thing. Rape is rape. And blaming the victim is not helpful in any way. Rapists cause rapes. End of.
If Mettyear was at a party and became so drunk that he fell asleep with his wallet on show and an opportunistic thief stole it from his pocket, would that mean it wasn't really theft? I am not suggesting that rape and theft are the same thing, but I am guessing that his opinion would differ in these circumstances.
Setford is a predator with no respect for women. He does not have good character. He is a rapist and incidentally he has a previous conviction for battery.
Mettyear should not be allowed his position of privilege. At the very least he needs some training, but I'd like to see men like him as far away from cases like this as possible. I hope that Setford's victim knows that it was not her fault. It was his fault. There is no excuse.
You can read the story that I read here: http://www.buzzfeed.com/alisonvingiano/not-a-classic-rapist
